Developments in AI-Driven Gaming Promotions: a Lawsuit, Regulator’s Questions, and New York’s Proposed Rules

by: Brian C. Schaller, Joyce Kim & Tina Reid

Scrutiny of AI-driven marketing in the gaming industry appears to be increasing. Our September 8 post covered proposed restrictions on AI-powered gaming promotions. Since then, other developments have followed:

  • In late September, a bettor filed a proposed nationwide class action against DraftKings that treats the responsible-play language in the company's privacy notices as a contractual promise.

  • On October 9, the Massachusetts Gaming Commission (the “Commission”) asked every sports wagering operator in the state how it uses AI and machine learning in marketing.

  • Also on October 9, the New York State Gaming Commission (NYSGC) formally advanced the AI restrictions we discussed in our September post.

This post covers each development and why they may matter to operators and to the vendors that are part of their marketing systems.

A Class Action Pleads the Privacy Notice as the Contract In Vest v. DraftKings, Inc., a West Virginia bettor seeks to represent everyone DraftKings deemed “elastic” or who received targeted messages or promotions “based on DraftKings' use of the Model.” According to the complaint, DraftKings built a machine learning model that scored each customer so that “[t]he higher the score, the more money a gambler was likely to lose for each promotion offered.” The complaint alleges that customers tagged "elastic" received extra emails, texts, and in-app notifications, along with extra promotions “intended to keep them gambling.”

The complaint pleads several counts, including breach of contract and implied contract, relying on a common theory in privacy litigation that treats the privacy notice itself as the contract. The contract counts rest on a “Responsible Play” disclosure that the complaint quotes from DraftKings' sportsbook and casino privacy notices, which states that DraftKings “may use the information collected about you to assess whether you are responsibly playing” and “may contact you to provide resources.” The complaint alleges that DraftKings instead used that information “for the exact opposite purpose.” It also states that the plaintiff will move to add a Massachusetts consumer protection claim under Chapter 93A if DraftKings does not make an acceptable settlemen tender within 30 days.

DraftKings disputes the allegations, reportedly stating that “DraftKings does not use AI to target customers based on losses, nor do we use AI to target customers based on indicators of potential problem gaming.” The court has not ruled on the allegations.

Massachusetts Asks Operators How Their Marketing Models Work

On September 24, Commission Chair Jordan Maynard directed staff to engage with all sports wagering operators about their use of AI and machine learning. Following that directive, the Executive Director issued an October 9 letter requesting operators for voluntary, confidential written responses to detailed questions regarding their use of AI, with particular focus on marketing and promotions. Among other things, the letter asks which systems come from third-party vendors, whether a patron's losses are an input into any promotional decision, and, where a vendor supplies the model, what “representations or assurances” the vendor has provided about whether the model “could encourage addictive or harmful gambling behavior.” It also asks whether the operator could identify the data, model, or factors behind a promotional decision.

The letter is a request for information, not an enforcement action. The questions sit alongside the Commission's sports wagering data privacy regulation, 205 CMR 257.00, which bars an operator from using patron data, “or any information derived from it,” to promote specific wagers or promotional offers based on “[a]ny computerized algorithm, automated decision-making, machine learning, artificial intelligence, or similar system that is known or reasonably expected by the Sports Wagering Operator or a vendor to the Sports Wagering Operator to make the gaming platform more addictive.” The DraftKings class action complaint discussed above also cites this regulation to bolster its claims.

New York Formally Proposes AI Limits That Reach Gaming Vendors

On October 9, the New York State Gaming Commission (NYSGC) approved the proposal to restrict how gaming licensees use artificial intelligence and other automated systems (see proposed text, here). The formal proposal substantially revises the March pre-proposal we discussed in our September 8 post. The pre-proposal would have barred licensees from “directly or indirectly” using artificial-intelligence-powered services to offer personalized promotions or suggested wagers or wager amounts. The formal proposal expressly bars licensees and any affiliate, agent, or vendor acting on a licensee’s behalf from using automated decision systems or algorithmic profiling of individual data to select, customize, time, or deliver promotions, odds, bonuses, limits, messages, or product recommendations; to suggest wagers, wager types, or wager amounts; or to otherwise influence wagering where the purpose or foreseeable effect is to increase wagering, engagement, or revenue. The first two prohibitions would apply regardless of purpose or effect. Licensees would be responsible for violations by their vendors. Neither human review of a system’s outputs nor a patron’s consent would make prohibited activity permissible. The proposal would carve out an exemption for pari-mutuel horse racing licensees that offer a dedicated application that suggests wagers, provided the patron first affirmatively opts in.

The rules are not in effect. As of the November 10 edition of the New York State Register, the NYSGC had not yet published the formal notice that starts the public comment period.

Why It Matters

Use of AI for marketing to players is drawing scrutiny from regulators and private litigants. Operators, vendors and their partners are in the crosshairs. Moreover, gaming operator privacy policies are being examined in connection with promises about how user data is being used to influence offers, pricing and overall game experience. These recent developments are a call to all businesses in the gaming ecosystem to understand how AI and user data is being used and to get into compliance. We can help.

Originally published by InfoLawGroup LLP. If you would like to receive regular emails from us, in which we share updates and our take on current legal news, please subscribe to InfoLawGroup’s Insights HERE. This summary does not constitute legal advice.